Mostra notizie nelle discussioni
  • Avatar
    Scritto da
    Non Autenticato
    il 2011-06-01 17:03:00.0 alle 2011-06-01 17:03:00.0
    Il mito di Google Summer of Code
    Ecco come funziona in realtà:

    I have been a GSoC student 3 times now (3rd is this year). Here’s my experience.

    I always hear some friends of mine that they are working with the mentor, or talking with them over the phone, IM, mail, yet this is so weird to me that I don’t even know where to start.

    Let’s take for example my last year involvment in GSoC. The actual mentor provided no feedback on my application. After being selected I sent the customary introduction email, got a response. I started sending weekly updates on the project, and various questions I had and got *NO* answer. At the end of the summer I got an email that the code looks clean and has been pushed to HEAD and it broke the build. Well d’oh, at least he could have asked me if it’s ok to do so.

    This year is the same.

    I know quite a few people in the same situation. So why would anyone stick when no one even bothers to read their e-mails? I remember sending a shitload of emails and man, the answers I got were like having 1000 monkeys at typewriters, or calling customer service.

    As far as I know most people mentoring in GSoC don’t have the time, or don’t care about the programs. The only people that do are the org administrators.

    Regards
    • Avatar
      Scritto da
      Non Autenticato
      il 2011-06-01 17:06:00.0 alle 2011-06-01 17:06:00.0
      Re: Il mito di Google Summer of Code

      - Scritto da:
      > Ecco come funziona in realtà:
      >
      > I have been a GSoC student 3 times now (3rd is
      > this year). Here’s my
      > experience.
      >
      > I always hear some friends of mine that they are
      > working with the mentor, or talking with them
      > over the phone, IM, mail, yet this is so weird to
      > me that I don’t even know where to
      > start.
      >
      > Let’s take for example my last year involvment in
      > GSoC. The actual mentor provided no feedback on
      > my application. After being selected I sent the
      > customary introduction email, got a response. I
      > started sending weekly updates on the project,
      > and various questions I had and got *NO* answer.
      > At the end of the summer I got an email that the
      > code looks clean and has been pushed to HEAD and
      > it broke the build. Well d’oh, at least he could
      > have asked me if it’s ok to do
      > so.
      >
      > This year is the same.
      >
      > I know quite a few people in the same situation.
      > So why would anyone stick when no one even
      > bothers to read their e-mails? I remember sending
      > a shitload of emails and man, the answers I got
      > were like having 1000 monkeys at typewriters, or
      > calling customer
      > service.
      >
      > As far as I know most people mentoring in GSoC
      > don’t have the time, or don’t care about the
      > programs. The only people that do are the org
      > administrators.
      >
      > Regards

      The sad thing is that I have some (pretty much) experience with FLOSS software and online communities, but have never actually been really involved in one, so I’m used to this sort of crap in FLOSS communities (devs not bothering to read your bug reports, they do so only if they *know* you, they don’t bother to read, try, provide feedback to patches, rude attitude without providing any real feedback) but most people won’t take this crap that long just for the sake of free software.

      PS: I would like to see how other students perceive GSoC or other mentoring programs.
<softv>

Pagina generata in 19 millisecondi

Utenti attivi: 30 nell'ultimo minuto, 95 negli ultimi cinque minuti, 160 negli ultimi 15 minuti